Baurecht · Architektenrecht · Immobilienrecht · Vergaberecht

horak Rechtsanwälte · Hanover and throughout Germany

Construction law with technical expertise.

We advise and represent clients, contractors, trades, architects, engineers, developers and public authorities – in private and public construction law, architects’ and engineers’ law, public procurement and real estate law in Germany.

  • since 2002active in construction and real estate law
  • 10offices – head office in Hanover
  • Dipl.-Ing. · Dipl.-Phys.engineering and science degrees in the team
  • ARGE Baurechtmembers of the German Bar Association’s construction and real estate law working group

Few areas of life are as heavily regulated as building. Anyone who develops a site, builds a house, carries out a construction contract or designs a building in Germany moves between the German Civil Code (BGB), the VOB, the HOAI fee scale, the Federal Building Code, the state building regulations and public procurement law. This introduction gives you an overview of the areas of law in which we advise – and of how they fit together.

Construction law – a cross-section of many areas of law

There is no single German “construction code”. Lawyers distinguish two main fields: private construction law governs the legal relationships between the parties to a project – client, contractor, trades, architects, engineers and developers. Public building law, by contrast, governs the relationship between the developer and the state: whether and how a site may be built on, which permits are required and which rights neighbours have.

Closely related fields complete the picture: architects’ and engineers’ law with the German fee scale for architects and engineers (HOAI), public procurement law for public contracts, real estate and property law, tenancy and brokerage law, and employment and criminal law on construction sites. In practice these fields overlap. A design error can jeopardise the building permit, trigger change orders from the contractor and give rise to the architect’s liability at the same time. Good advice therefore keeps the whole project in view.

Private construction law: contracts, payment and defects

At the heart of private construction law is the construction contract. Since 2018 the BGB has contained specific rules on the construction contract, the consumer construction contract, the architect’s and engineer’s contract and the developer contract. In addition, many parties agree on the VOB/B, a set of standard terms with its own rules on completion dates, disruption, change orders, invoicing, acceptance and warranty. Which set of rules applies and how it is validly incorporated often decides the outcome of a later dispute.

During construction, change orders and construction time take centre stage: if the client changes the design or orders additional work, the question of additional payment arises. If the project is delayed, the issues are notices of disruption, contractual penalties and damages. Finally, acceptance (Abnahme) shifts the burden of proof for defects, makes the price due and starts the limitation period for defect claims. Contractors secure their payment through the builder’s security under section 650f BGB and the security mortgage; clients secure their position through guarantees and retentions.

Design, engineering and project development

Architects and engineers generally owe not merely drawings but a design that actually works. Architects’ and engineers’ law clarifies which services are owed, how they are remunerated under the HOAI or by free agreement, and when designers are liable for construction defects or cost overruns. Copyright in plans and buildings and the professional rules of the chambers also play a role.

Whether work is defective is often decided by the generally recognised rules of engineering, DIN standards and the assessment of construction experts. In developer and project development law, the purchase of land, the obligation to build and instalment payments under the German Brokers and Developers Ordinance (MaBV) come together – a constellation with particular risks for buyers and developers.

Public building law: what may be built where

Federal planning law (the Federal Building Code and the Land Use Ordinance) determines which uses are permitted on a site – within the scope of a development plan, in the unplanned built-up area or in the outskirts. The building regulations of the federal states, in Lower Saxony the NBauO, govern setback areas, fire protection, parking spaces and the permit procedure. Municipalities steer urban development through land-use and development plans and through urban development contracts with investors.

If a building application is refused, granted subject to conditions or challenged by a neighbour, it is essential to act quickly and within the deadlines: objection, action and urgent proceedings before the administrative court. Neighbour law is where public and private law meet – from setback areas and boundary development to public building encumbrances (Baulasten) and emissions.

Public procurement: awarding and winning public contracts securely

Public contracting authorities must tender construction, design and other services according to strict rules. Above the EU thresholds, the Act against Restraints of Competition (GWB), the Procurement Ordinance (VgV) and the VOB/A-EU apply; below them, budget law, the VOB/A and the Sub-threshold Procurement Rules (UVgO). For bidders: procurement errors must be raised early, otherwise they are excluded in review proceedings. For contracting authorities: a carefully prepared award procedure is the best protection against delays.

Real estate law: property, use and transactions

Every construction project starts with a site. Real estate law covers the purchase and sale of land and buildings, due diligence, easements such as rights of way and utility rights, hereditary building rights and condominium ownership. Once a building is completed, questions of use follow – in particular in commercial tenancy law and brokerage law.

Resolving construction disputes

Construction lawsuits are technically demanding, costly and often lengthy. That is why it pays to tackle conflicts early and in a structured way: through negotiation, conciliation, mediation or adjudication. Where a court decision cannot be avoided, independent evidence proceedings preserve evidence of the condition of the building and suspend the limitation period. Complex projects and international contracts often provide for arbitration. We also advise on employment and criminal law risks on site, for example the general contractor’s liability for the minimum wage and social security contributions.

On the following pages you will find a detailed description of the most important contracts, procedures and questions for each of these topics. Every case is different, however: for a reliable assessment, please contact us directly.

Practice areas

16 practice areas – grouped by topic

Every construction project touches several areas of law. Choose your topic – the detail pages cover contracts, procedures, typical questions and our services.

How we work

Support in every project phase

Construction disputes are expensive and time-consuming. That is why we get involved early – and are there for you if a conflict does arise.

  1. 1

    Project set-up & design

    Checking the site, planning law and permit prospects, defining the project structure and procurement strategy, drafting architects’ and engineers’ contracts.

  2. 2

    Tender & contract

    Tendering, construction contracts under the German Civil Code (BGB) or VOB/B, general contractor and subcontractor agreements, balanced securities and liquidated damages.

  3. 3

    Construction phase

    Legal support during construction, change order and disruption management, construction time, interim invoices and communication with all parties.

  4. 4

    Acceptance & warranty

    Preparing acceptance, notifying and enforcing defects, checking the final invoice, releasing or drawing on securities.

  5. 5

    Dispute resolution

    Negotiation, conciliation and mediation, independent evidence proceedings, construction litigation and arbitration – with an eye on cost and duration.

Why horak

Law and engineering under one roof

Construction cases are often decided at the interface between engineering and law: is it a design error or a workmanship error? Does the work comply with the generally recognised rules of engineering? Is a change order justified in principle and in amount? Several of our lawyers hold degrees in engineering or natural sciences and speak the language of planners, experts and site managers.

At the same time, we combine construction law with neighbouring disciplines of our firm: intellectual property and copyright (for example copyright in plans and buildings), public procurement and real estate law.

More about the firm
Besprechungsraum der Kanzlei horak Rechtsanwälte
  • Both sides of the construction contract. We know the perspective of clients and contractors – which makes contracts robust and negotiations efficient.
  • From single-family homes to major projects. Private clients benefit from the same care as companies and municipalities.
  • Network of experts. We work with construction experts from various disciplines.
  • National and cross-border. Ten offices in Germany and experience with international contract forms such as FIDIC.
  • Clear communication. Understandable assessments of prospects, risks and costs – before you decide.

Enquiry

Tell us about your matter

Briefly describe your project or question. We will check who in our team is best placed to help and get back to you with an initial assessment of the next steps and costs.

Please note: if a deadline is running – for example for a notice of defects, an objection or a complaint in a procurement procedure – please also call us.

We use your details only to process your enquiry. For details, please see our privacy policy.

Encrypted transmission. An enquiry does not create a client relationship; deadlines cannot be met via this form.