Engineers design the technical foundations of a building – from structural engineering to building services. Their services are highly specialised, and the liability risks are correspondingly high. As a firm with its own engineering background, we know both worlds.
Fields of activity
Engineers‘ law covers all legal questions relating to the work of engineers in construction, in particular in structural design, building services (MEP), building physics, geotechnics, the design of civil engineering structures and transport infrastructure, and surveying. The legal basis comprises the German Civil Code, the HOAI, the engineering acts of the federal states and technical standards.
Engineering contracts
Engineering contracts are generally contracts for work within the meaning of sections 650p et seq. BGB; the engineer owes a defect-free design result. Consulting and expert activities can also be structured as a contract for services. The contract should in particular regulate:
- Scope of services, with basic and special services
- Design basis, duties to cooperate and interfaces with other designers
- Deadlines, drawing delivery schedules and change management
- Fees, incidental costs and payment for additional services
- Limitation of liability and insurance cover
- Rights of use in drawings, calculations and software
Fees and remuneration models
The HOAI contains scopes of services for specialist design such as structural design and building services, as well as for civil engineering structures and transport infrastructure. As for architects, the fee tables have been guideline values since 2021; agreements must be in text form. Time-based and lump-sum fees are also common. For services outside the HOAI, such as fire protection or energy consulting, a clear contractual provision is particularly important.
Liability of engineers
Typical liability cases are calculation and dimensioning errors, insufficient consideration of ground conditions, lack of coordination with other trades, errors in tender documents and delays in delivering drawings. Engineers may be liable not only to their client but in some circumstances also to third parties. Adequate professional indemnity insurance and effective contractual limitations of liability are indispensable.
Professional law and competition
The professional title „Ingenieur“ (engineer) is protected by the engineering acts of the federal states. Additional requirements and duties of the chambers of engineers apply to consulting engineers, inspecting engineers and certified inspectors. We also advise on competition law issues – for example advertising by engineering firms – and on protecting technical solutions through patents and utility models.
Procurement of engineering services
Above the EU thresholds, public contracting authorities usually award design services in a negotiated procedure with a prior call for competition under the German Public Procurement Regulation (VgV). Engineering firms must compile evidence of suitability and references carefully. We support applications and represent firms in the event of procurement errors – more under public procurement law.
Our services
- Drafting and reviewing engineering and specialist design contracts
- Fee calculations, fee agreements and fee actions
- Defending liability claims, coordination with the professional indemnity insurer
- Professional law, chamber matters and competition law
- Protecting technical innovations in cooperation with our patent attorneys
Case studies
Structural error and joint liability
Situation: After cracks appeared in a hall, a structural engineer was held liable alongside the shell contractor.
Approach: We broke down the shares of causation with an expert report and claimed internal compensation.
Outcome: The shell contractor took over most of the damage.
Additional fees under an engineering contract
Situation: An MEP designer had to redo its design after several change requests from the client.
Approach: We calculated and documented the repeated services under the HOAI.
Outcome: The client paid an additional fee.
Insurance cover secured
Situation: An engineering firm’s liability insurer refused cover on the grounds of an alleged breach of duty.
Approach: We examined the insurance conditions and rejected the refusal.
Outcome: The insurer took over the defence of the claims.
The examples are anonymised and simplified. They illustrate typical situations; every case is different, and no particular outcome can be promised.
Frequently asked questions
Can I limit my liability as an engineer by contract?
A limitation of liability is possible within certain limits, for example to the sum insured under the professional indemnity insurance. In standard terms, however, liability for intent, gross negligence and injury to life, body and health may not be excluded.
Does the structural engineer also owe supervision of the works?
Not automatically. In structural design, site supervision is a special service that must be commissioned separately. This is to be distinguished from the building control review by inspecting engineers.
Last updated: · horak Rechtsanwälte, Hanover. General information under German law, not legal advice in an individual case.