Baurecht · Architektenrecht · Immobilienrecht · Vergaberecht

Construction litigation before the civil courts

Construction cases are technical and lengthy. Winning them takes a well-thought-out strategy and clean pleadings from the outset.

Construction litigation is considered particularly demanding: it involves many individual items, technical questions and extensive documents. Many regional courts and higher regional courts have set up specialised construction chambers and senates (sections 72a, 119a GVG). What matters is a presentation that clearly links items, evidence and legal basis.

Typical claims

  • Claims for payment after acceptance or termination, including change orders
  • Claims for an advance on costs or reimbursement of the cost of remedying defects
  • Damages for delay, additional costs from disrupted construction
  • Recovery of overpayments and return of securities
  • Fee claims by architects and engineers

Strategy and pleadings

Even before filing, we clarify the evidence: site diaries, correspondence, measurements, photos and witnesses. For delay claims, the courts require a specific presentation of each disruption and its effects on the actual sequence of works. For defects, describing the symptoms is sufficient; the court addresses the causes through experts. Verifiable final invoices and a comprehensible calculation of change orders are the basis of every payment claim.

Instances and costs

Depending on the amount in dispute, the local court or the regional court has jurisdiction; representation by a lawyer is mandatory before the regional court. Judgments can be appealed to the higher regional court – for the Hanover district, the Higher Regional Court of Celle. Because expert costs can be considerable, we always examine whether a settlement or prior evidence proceedings would be more economical.

Our services

  • Litigation risk analysis and cost estimate before filing
  • Statements of claim and defence with a structured overview of items
  • Involving private experts and accompanying court-appointed expert reports
  • Settlement negotiations, appeals and complaints against refusal of leave to appeal

Case studies

Payment enforced after termination

Situation: A client terminated a drywall contractor for convenience and refused any payment for the work not performed.

Approach: We invoiced the work performed and not performed separately and derived the saved expenses from the calculation.

Outcome: The regional court awarded most of the claim; the client’s appeal was unsuccessful.

Advance on costs for façade repair

Situation: Façade panels were coming loose on an office building; the contractor refused to remedy the defects.

Approach: After a deadline had passed without result, we sued for an advance and used the results of evidence proceedings.

Outcome: The contractor was ordered to pay the advance; the parties later agreed on the final account.

Delay claim defended

Situation: A general contractor claimed lump-sum additional costs for a construction time extension of several months.

Approach: We showed that disruptions had not been notified and that their effects had not been presented in relation to the actual sequence of works.

Outcome: The claim was largely dismissed.

The examples are anonymised and simplified. They illustrate typical situations; every case is different, and no particular outcome can be promised.

Frequently asked questions

How long does construction litigation take?

At first instance often one to two years, longer if expert reports are needed. Prior evidence proceedings can shorten the main action considerably.

Is a settlement worthwhile?

Often, yes. A settlement saves expert and court costs and quickly creates certainty. We assess the prospects of success soberly so that you can make an informed decision.

Last updated: · horak Rechtsanwälte, Hanover. General information under German law, not legal advice in an individual case.