Public contracts are an important market for many construction companies and design firms. Public procurement law ensures competition, transparency and equal treatment – and imposes strict formal requirements on contracting authorities and bidders alike. In our team, a specialist lawyer for public procurement law (Fachanwältin für Vergaberecht) advises you.
Legal basis
German procurement law has two tiers. Above the EU thresholds, the European procurement directives apply, implemented in the Act against Restraints of Competition (GWB, sections 97 et seq.), the Public Procurement Regulation (VgV), the Sector Regulation (SektVO), the Concession Award Regulation (KonzVgV) and, for construction work, section 2 of the VOB/A (VOB/A-EU). Below the thresholds, awards are governed by budget law, section 1 of the VOB/A, the Sub-Threshold Procurement Regulation (UVgO) and the state procurement acts – in Lower Saxony the NTVergG.
The thresholds are adjusted by the European Commission every two years; for works contracts they amount to several million euros, while for supplies and services – including design services – they are considerably lower.
Types of procedure
- Open procedureAll interested companies may submit a tender.
- Restricted procedureSelection of suitable candidates in a prior call for competition.
- Negotiated procedureNegotiations on tenders; standard for architectural and engineering services.
- Competitive dialogueFor complex contracts where the contracting authority cannot yet define the solution.
- Innovation partnershipDevelopment and subsequent purchase of innovative services.
- Below the thresholdsPublic and restricted tendering, negotiated award, direct award.
Suitability, tender and award
Bidders must prove their suitability – expertise, capacity and reliability – through evidence and references. Formal errors, missing declarations or impermissible changes to the tender documents quickly lead to exclusion. The contract is awarded to the most economically advantageous tender, which can take into account not only price but also quality, deadlines, sustainability or concepts. Abnormally low tenders must be investigated.
Legal protection for bidders
- Complaint: recognised procurement infringements must be raised within 10 calendar days; infringements apparent from the contract notice or the tender documents at the latest by the end of the tender period (section 160(3) GWB).
- Advance notice: the contracting authority must inform unsuccessful bidders of the intended award; the contract may only be awarded after a standstill period of 10 or 15 calendar days (section 134 GWB).
- Application for review: before the public procurement tribunal, no later than 15 calendar days after notice that the complaint will not be remedied. Once the application has been served, the contract may not be awarded.
- Immediate appeal: to the procurement senate of the higher regional court.
A contract that has already been awarded can only be challenged in exceptional cases, for example in the case of an impermissible direct award. Claims for damages may also be considered.
Advice for contracting authorities
We support municipalities, public companies and recipients of public funding in choosing the type of procedure, dividing contracts into lots, preparing tender documents and award criteria, examining tenders and defending review proceedings. Recipients of public funding must also observe procurement law – infringements can lead to funding being reclaimed.
Our services
- Reviewing tender documents and supporting the preparation of tenders
- Bidder questions, complaints, review and appeal proceedings
- Designing and conducting award procedures for contracting authorities
- Award of architectural and engineering services under the VgV
- Funding and grant law in connection with procurement
Case studies
Contract won after a complaint
Situation: A landscaping company was excluded because its tender was supposedly incomplete.
Approach: We raised a complaint within two days and pointed out the obligation to request missing documents.
Outcome: The contracting authority remedied the complaint, and our client won the contract.
Tender designed to be legally sound
Situation: A municipal housing company wanted to tender construction work EU-wide for the first time.
Approach: We determined the type of procedure, lots, suitability and award criteria and reviewed the documents.
Outcome: The procedure ran without a review application; all lots were awarded on time.
Funding secured
Situation: A funding recipient faced reclaim of grants because of procurement errors.
Approach: We reworked the procurement documentation and assessed the seriousness of the infringements.
Outcome: The reclaim was reduced to a small partial amount.
The examples are anonymised and simplified. They illustrate typical situations; every case is different, and no particular outcome can be promised.
Frequently asked questions
I have found an error in the tender documents – what now?
Raise the error with the contracting authority immediately and at the latest by the end of the tender period. If you do not complain in time, the error can no longer be asserted later in review proceedings. Alternatively, a bidder question may be useful for clarification.
What do review proceedings cost?
The fees of the procurement tribunal depend on the contract value and amount to at least EUR 2,500, but usually considerably more. In addition, there are lawyers‘ fees. We assess the prospects of success and the cost risk with you in advance.
Last updated: · horak Rechtsanwälte, Hanover. General information under German law, not legal advice in an individual case.