In construction, both sides protect themselves: the client against non-performance and defects, the contractor against non-payment. Whether a security holds up in an emergency depends on a valid agreement and on the wording of the guarantee.
Securities for the client
- Performance security: according to case law, generally permissible in standard terms up to 10 percent of the contract sum.
- Defects security: in practice usually 3 to 5 percent; higher rates in standard terms are problematic.
- Retention: in standard terms, it must be balanced by an option to replace it, for example with a guarantee.
- Guarantees payable on first demand cannot validly be required in standard terms.
Securities for the contractor
The contractor can demand security from the client for the unpaid price, including change orders (section 650f BGB). This right cannot be excluded by contract. If the client does not provide it, the contractor may suspend work or terminate. In addition, there is a claim to a security mortgage over the building plot (section 650e BGB).
Return and calling of securities
Securities must be returned after the agreed period has expired, insofar as no claims exist. When calling on a guarantor, the purpose of the security and timely assertion are decisive.
Case studies
Guarantee returned
Situation: A façade contractor had been waiting two years after the end of the warranty period for the return of its EUR 180,000 guarantee.
Approach: We demanded its return and claimed the guarantee fees as damages.
Outcome: The guarantee was returned and the fees were reimbursed.
Contractor’s security enforced
Situation: A steel construction company had substantial outstanding claims against a project developer.
Approach: We demanded security under section 650f BGB with a deadline and prepared to suspend work.
Outcome: The client provided a bank guarantee, and the work continued.
Guarantor pays after insolvency
Situation: After a shell contractor became insolvent, the client claimed the additional completion costs from the guarantor.
Approach: We documented the additional costs comprehensibly and examined the purpose of the guarantee.
Outcome: The guarantor paid the secured amount.
The examples are anonymised and simplified. They illustrate typical situations; every case is different, and no particular outcome can be promised.
Frequently asked questions
Can I demand a contractor’s security even after acceptance?
Yes. The claim also exists after acceptance as long as payment is outstanding.
How long must a warranty guarantee be provided?
That depends on the contract. Under a VOB/B contract, a security that has not been called must generally be returned after two years unless otherwise agreed.
Last updated: · horak Rechtsanwälte, Hanover. General information under German law, not legal advice in an individual case.