Independent evidence proceedings (sections 485 et seq. of the German Code of Civil Procedure, ZPO) are the most important tool for establishing the condition of a building with binding effect. An expert appointed by the court assesses defects, their causes and the cost of remedying them. In later litigation, the result has the same effect as if the evidence had been taken there.
When the proceedings are worthwhile
The proceedings are a good option when defects are disputed, when a building element is soon to be covered up or repaired, or when claims are about to become time-barred. They can be applied for even without pending litigation, provided there is a legal interest in the findings. In construction matters, this interest generally exists because the expert report can avoid a lawsuit.
Procedure
- Application: The questions for the expert are formulated specifically, and the defects are described by their visible symptoms. The applicant does not need to know the causes.
- Order: The court orders the taking of evidence and appoints the expert. The applicant pays an advance on costs.
- Site inspection and report: All parties are summoned. Opening up building elements is often part of the assessment.
- Supplementary questions and hearing: The parties can ask supplementary questions and request that the expert explain the report orally.
Limitation and third-party notice
Service of the application suspends the limitation period for the claims to which the proceedings relate (section 204(1) no. 7 BGB). The suspension ends six months after the proceedings have concluded. Anyone with several potentially responsible parties, such as the contractor, designer and site supervisor, should serve third-party notices on them early so that the result is also binding on them.
Our services
- Assessing whether evidence proceedings or a private expert report make more sense
- Drafting applications and questions for the expert, selecting suitable experts
- Attending site inspections and critically reviewing expert reports
- Defending contractors and designers as respondents or third parties
Case studies
Damp basement before a sale
Situation: An owner wanted to sell their house; damp appeared in the basement, and the waterproofing contractor denied any defect.
Approach: We applied for evidence proceedings and brought in the designer and site supervisor by third-party notice.
Outcome: The expert found defective waterproofing. The waterproofing contractor and the designer shared the cost of repair, and no main action was necessary.
Limitation suspended at the last minute
Situation: A few weeks before the warranty period expired, cracks appeared in the ceiling of an underground car park owned by a community of owners.
Approach: We filed the application at short notice and described the symptoms so that all possible causes were covered.
Outcome: The limitation period was suspended in time, and the claims against the shell contractor were preserved.
Contractor successfully defended
Situation: A client accused a window installer of leaking joints and demanded that all windows be replaced.
Approach: We asked supplementary questions on the cause and requested a hearing of the expert.
Outcome: The cause was façade waterproofing provided by the client. In the end, the client bore the costs of the proceedings.
The examples are anonymised and simplified. They illustrate typical situations; every case is different, and no particular outcome can be promised.
Frequently asked questions
How long do independent evidence proceedings take?
Depending on scope and the experts‘ workload, usually several months to more than a year. Supplementary reports extend the proceedings.
Who bears the costs?
Initially the applicant, through the advance. The costs are allocated in the subsequent main action or in a settlement; on application, the court can set the applicant a deadline for filing an action.
Last updated: · horak Rechtsanwälte, Hanover. General information under German law, not legal advice in an individual case.