Municipalities steer development through land-use planning. For investors, it determines whether and how a project can be realised; for owners and neighbours, what will be built in their surroundings.
Land-use plan and development plan
The preparatory land-use plan (Flächennutzungsplan) shows the intended type of land use for the entire municipal area in broad terms. The development plan (Bebauungsplan) is derived from it and, as a by-law, lays down binding provisions:
- Type of use: for example purely or generally residential area, mixed area, urban area, commercial or special area (BauNVO)
- Intensity of use: site occupancy index (GRZ), floor area ratio (GFZ), number of full storeys, building heights
- Building pattern and buildable areas: open or closed building pattern, building lines and building limits
- Traffic areas, green spaces, areas for utilities and compensation measures
A distinction is made between the qualified, the simple and the project-related development plan (section 12 BauGB). The latter is drawn up on the basis of an investor’s project and infrastructure plan and supplemented by an implementation agreement.
The plan-making procedure
- Resolution by the municipality to draw up the plan (section 2 BauGB)
- Early participation of the public and the authorities (sections 3(1), 4(1) BauGB)
- Environmental assessment and environmental report
- Publication of the draft and formal participation (sections 3(2), 4(2) BauGB)
- Balancing of all public and private interests (section 1(7) BauGB)
- Adoption as a by-law and publication (section 10 BauGB)
An accelerated procedure is available for inner-city development measures (section 13a BauGB). Owners and neighbours should submit their objections in the participation procedure in good time and with substantiation.
Legal protection against development plans
A development plan can be reviewed by the higher administrative court by way of judicial review (section 47 VwGO). The application must be filed within one year of publication; anyone who claims that their rights are infringed has standing. In addition, the invalidity of a plan can be raised incidentally in other proceedings. Certain procedural and balancing errors become irrelevant if they are not raised within one year (section 215 BauGB).
Urban development contracts
Through urban development contracts (section 11 BauGB), municipalities transfer tasks and costs to investors, for example:
- Planning agreementsPreparation of the plan and expert reports by the investor.
- Follow-up cost agreementsContribution to the costs of day-care centres, schools or infrastructure caused by the project.
- Infrastructure agreementsConstruction of roads, utilities and green spaces by a private developer.
- Commitment agreementsObligations to build, quotas for subsidised housing, local resident schemes, energy standards.
The agreed performance must be appropriate and materially connected to the project (prohibition of coupling). Inappropriate contracts are void.
Public-private partnerships
In PPP models, private partners take on the design, construction, financing and operation of public infrastructure such as schools, administrative buildings or roads over long terms. Common models are build-operate-transfer (BOT), design-build-finance-operate (DBFO) and concession models. We advise on contract structure, risk allocation, classification under procurement law and questions of early termination.
Our services
- Supporting plan-making procedures for investors, project sponsors and municipalities
- Objections in the participation procedure
- Drafting and negotiating urban development contracts and implementation agreements
- Judicial review proceedings
- Structuring PPP projects
Case studies
Urban development contract for a residential area
Situation: A municipality wanted to transfer the costs of developing infrastructure for a new building area to the project sponsor.
Approach: We drafted an infrastructure and follow-up cost agreement with appropriate obligations.
Outcome: The contract was concluded, and the building area has been developed.
Project-related development plan
Situation: A company wanted to build a hotel that the existing plan did not permit.
Approach: We negotiated the implementation agreement and supported the plan-making procedure.
Outcome: The project-related development plan entered into force, and the hotel was built.
Objections in the plan-making procedure
Situation: A farmer feared that a new building area would prevent the expansion of his livestock business.
Approach: We submitted comments and expert reports in the participation procedure.
Outcome: The municipality reduced the plan area and secured land for expansion.
The examples are anonymised and simplified. They illustrate typical situations; every case is different, and no particular outcome can be promised.
Frequently asked questions
Can I apply for a development plan for my plot?
There is no right to have a development plan drawn up (section 1(3) BauGB). Investors can, however, propose a project-related development plan to the municipality and bear the planning costs. The municipal council decides.
How do I defend myself against a planned development plan in my neighbourhood?
Submit your objections in the participation procedure while the plan is still being drawn up. Once it has entered into force, an application for judicial review is possible within one year. Direct dialogue with the municipality and the project sponsor is often worthwhile too.
Last updated: · horak Rechtsanwälte, Hanover. General information under German law, not legal advice in an individual case.