Hardly any construction project is without effects on the neighbourhood. Whether shading, noise, boundary distances or site operations – neighbour disputes are emotional and legally complex, because private and public law interlock.
Private neighbour law
- Ownership and defensive rights: the owner can defend against interference with their land (sections 903, 1004 BGB) but must tolerate insignificant or locally customary effects (section 906 BGB); a compensation claim may exist in some circumstances.
- Encroachment: if a building was built over the boundary without intent, the neighbour may have to tolerate the encroachment in return for an annuity (section 912 BGB).
- Excavation: excavation pits must not deprive the neighbouring land of support (section 909 BGB).
- Trees, hedges, roots: overhang and boundary distances under section 910 BGB and the neighbour law acts of the federal states, in Lower Saxony the NNachbG.
- Right of access for building work (Hammerschlags- und Leiterrecht): entering the neighbouring land for construction work under the conditions of state law.
- Boundary walls, window and light rights: special rules under state law.
Neighbour protection under public law
Neighbours can only challenge a building permit if it infringes provisions that also serve to protect them – such as setback areas, provisions on the type of use (right to preserve the character of the area) or the duty of consideration in the case of an overpowering effect or unreasonable emissions. The legal remedy generally has no suspensive effect; to prevent construction from starting, an urgent application to the administrative court is required (sections 80a, 80(5) VwGO).
Deadlines: if the permit is notified to the neighbour, a one-month period runs. Otherwise, the right may be forfeited in good faith if the neighbour remains inactive for a long time despite knowing about the construction. Developers are therefore often well advised to have the permit served on neighbours.
Building encumbrances (Baulasten)
A building encumbrance is a public-law obligation of a landowner towards the building control authority to do, tolerate or refrain from something. It is entered in the register of building encumbrances – not in the land register – and is also effective against later owners. Building encumbrances exist in almost all federal states, in Lower Saxony under the NBauO; Bavaria has no law on building encumbrances.
- Setback encumbranceThe neighbour takes over setback areas on their land.
- Unification encumbranceSeveral plots are treated as one plot under building law.
- Access encumbranceSecuring access across someone else’s land.
- Parking encumbranceRequired parking spaces are provided on another plot.
A building encumbrance does not in itself create a private right of use. It should therefore generally be accompanied by an easement. Building encumbrances often reduce the value of land and should be checked before any purchase. The authority may waive an encumbrance if there is no longer a public interest.
Our services
- Assessing the prospects of neighbour objections and actions
- Urgent proceedings against and in defence of building permits
- Civil law claims for injunction, removal and compensation
- Agreements with neighbours: site access, anchors, crane oversailing, boundary development
- Creating, reviewing and deleting building encumbrances
Case studies
Building encumbrance for access
Situation: A backland plot could only be accessed via the neighbouring plot.
Approach: We negotiated an agreement with compensation and arranged registration of a building encumbrance.
Outcome: Access was secured, and the building permit was granted.
Boundary encroachment ended
Situation: A neighbour built a garage partly on our client’s land.
Approach: We had the boundary surveyed and demanded removal.
Outcome: The neighbour moved the garage wall.
Right of access for building work
Situation: A developer needed to enter the neighbouring plot to insulate the façade; the neighbour refused.
Approach: We asserted the claims under the Lower Saxony Neighbour Law Act and offered compensation.
Outcome: The neighbour tolerated the work in return for a security deposit.
The examples are anonymised and simplified. They illustrate typical situations; every case is different, and no particular outcome can be promised.
Frequently asked questions
Can I prevent my neighbour from building a large house next to me?
Only if the building permit infringes neighbour-protecting provisions, for example if setback areas are not observed or the duty of consideration is breached. As a rule, there is no „right to an unobstructed view“. We examine the permit and the plans.
Do I have to allow my neighbour to enter my land for their building work?
The neighbour law acts of the federal states provide for a right of access under certain conditions, usually subject to prior notice and compensation for damage. Ground anchors or crane oversailing generally require separate agreements.
Last updated: · horak Rechtsanwälte, Hanover. General information under German law, not legal advice in an individual case.