Under section 650a BGB, a construction contract is a contract for the construction, restoration, removal or alteration of a building or outdoor facility. In addition to the general law on contracts for work, special rules apply which mainly govern changes during construction.
Right to order changes and negotiation phase
If the client requests a change to the agreed result of the work, or a change that is necessary to achieve that result, the parties should first try to agree on the change and on the increase or reduction in price. The contractor must generally submit an offer for this. If no agreement is reached within 30 days, the client may order the change in text form (section 650b BGB).
Price adjustment
The increase or reduction in price is calculated on the basis of the costs actually required, plus reasonable mark-ups for general overheads, risk and profit. The contractor may also rely on an original cost calculation deposited as agreed. Until agreement or a court decision, the contractor may include 80 percent of its change order offer in interim invoices (section 650c BGB).
Other special features
- Interim injunction in disputes over a change order or its price, without having to substantiate urgency once construction has started (section 650d BGB)
- Security mortgage and contractor’s security (sections 650e, 650f BGB)
- Joint condition survey where acceptance is refused (section 650g BGB), with a presumption regarding obvious defects
- Verifiable final invoice as a condition for payment becoming due (section 650g(4) BGB)
- Written form for any termination (section 650h BGB)
When the BGB construction contract is the better choice
The statutory construction contract is balanced and avoids the standard-terms risks of a modified VOB/B. For clients it can be more favourable because of the five-year limitation period for defect claims. Contractors benefit from the 80 percent rule and easier access to interim relief. Which option fits depends on the project, your role and your negotiating position.
Case studies
Dispute over a design change
Situation: After construction had started, a client ordered a different façade design and rejected the change order offer as excessive.
Approach: For the contractor, we used the 80 percent rule for interim payments and converted the calculation to the costs actually required.
Outcome: Liquidity was secured; the final price was set in negotiations with an expert.
Condition survey instead of acceptance
Situation: A client refused to accept an extension because of alleged defects, without specifying them.
Approach: At our request, a joint condition survey was carried out and recorded.
Outcome: Obvious defects alleged later were, under the presumption in section 650g BGB, not attributable to the contractor.
Urgent proceedings over a change order
Situation: A client demanded that a design change be carried out; the contractor considered it unreasonable.
Approach: We applied for an interim injunction under section 650d BGB without having to substantiate urgency.
Outcome: The court decided within a few weeks, and construction continued without a standstill.
The examples are anonymised and simplified. They illustrate typical situations; every case is different, and no particular outcome can be promised.
Frequently asked questions
Does the new construction contract law apply to all contracts?
It applies to contracts concluded on or after 1 January 2018. Older contracts remain subject to the previous contract-for-work law.
Does a change order have to be in writing?
Under section 650b BGB, text form is sufficient, for example an email. Oral instructions should always be confirmed in text form.
Last updated: · horak Rechtsanwälte, Hanover. General information under German law, not legal advice in an individual case.