Baurecht · Architektenrecht · Immobilienrecht · Vergaberecht

Architect and engineer agreement

Scope, fees and liability: we draft design contracts that fit the project and avoid disputes over additional claims.

Since 2018, the German Civil Code has contained its own rules for architect and engineer agreements (sections 650p–650t BGB). Since 2021, the German fee scale for architects and engineers (HOAI) only sets guideline values for fees. A contract that clearly defines services and remuneration is therefore all the more important.

Goal-definition phase and special right of termination

If the key design and supervision goals have not yet been agreed when the contract is concluded, the designer first prepares a design basis with a cost estimate. Once it has been presented, the client may terminate the contract within two weeks (sections 650p(2), 650r BGB); for consumers, this only applies if they were informed of this right.

Fees under the HOAI 2021

Fees can be freely agreed; the agreement must be in text form. Without a valid agreement, the base rate of the relevant fee table applies. Special services, the surcharge for alterations and incidental costs should be expressly regulated.

Key provisions

  • Scope of services, commissioned work stages and staged commissioning
  • Cost caps or construction cost agreements
  • Deadlines and the client’s duties to cooperate
  • Copyright and rights of use in the design
  • Partial acceptance after work stage 8 (section 650s BGB)
  • Limitation of liability and professional indemnity insurance

Case studies

Staged commissioning

Situation: A client initially commissioned only work stages 1 to 4 and wanted to continue the design with another firm later.

Approach: We regulated the call-off option, the rights of use in the design and the fee if further stages are not called off.

Outcome: The change of designer was possible without any dispute over copyright.

Fees without text form

Situation: An engineering firm had only discussed its fees orally and invoiced at the maximum rate.

Approach: We set out the legal position under the HOAI 2021.

Outcome: The invoice was settled at the base rate; the difference was not paid.

Cost cap exceeded

Situation: An architect had significantly exceeded a budget of EUR 2.1 million.

Approach: We established the cost target as an agreed quality of the work and calculated the client’s loss.

Outcome: The architect and their insurer contributed to the additional costs.

The examples are anonymised and simplified. They illustrate typical situations; every case is different, and no particular outcome can be promised.

Frequently asked questions

Are the HOAI minimum rates still binding?

No. Since the HOAI 2021, the fee rates are guideline values. The remuneration agreed in the contract is binding.

When do claims against the architect become time-barred?

For design and supervision services for a building, usually five years from acceptance of the architect’s services.

Last updated: · horak Rechtsanwälte, Hanover. General information under German law, not legal advice in an individual case.