In arbitration (sections 1025 et seq. ZPO), a private arbitral tribunal decides instead of the state courts. The parties choose the arbitrators themselves and can thus ensure expertise in construction technology and construction law. The award is final and can only be set aside within narrow limits.
Arbitration agreement
Arbitration requires an arbitration agreement, usually as a clause in the construction contract. It should specify the arbitration rules, the number of arbitrators, the seat and the language. With consumers, the agreement must be set out in a separate document signed by the parties (section 1031(5) ZPO).
Arbitration rules
In construction, the German conciliation and arbitration rules for construction disputes (SOBau) and the construction dispute rules (SL Bau) are widely used. For larger and international projects, the arbitration rules of the German Arbitration Institute (DIS) or the ICC are often chosen. Each set of rules has its own provisions on time limits and costs.
Advantages and limits
- Confidentiality and expertise of the arbitrators
- Flexible procedure, only one instance
- International enforceability under the New York Convention
- On the other hand, higher initial costs and no appeal
Our services
- Drafting and reviewing arbitration clauses
- Representation as claimant or respondent before arbitral tribunals
- Declarations of enforceability and setting-aside proceedings before the higher regional court
Case studies
Award in plant engineering
Situation: A machine builder was in dispute with an industrial customer over the acceptance of a production line and contractual penalties.
Approach: We conducted the proceedings under the agreed arbitration rules and nominated a technical arbitrator.
Outcome: The tribunal rejected the contractual penalty and awarded the outstanding contract price.
Invalid arbitration clause with private buyers
Situation: A developer relied on an arbitration clause in the purchase agreement against private buyers.
Approach: On behalf of the buyers, we objected that the form required for arbitration agreements with consumers had not been observed.
Outcome: The action before the state court was allowed to proceed.
Confidential settlement in arbitration
Situation: On a hospital project, the general designer and the client were in dispute over design errors and fees.
Approach: After the taking of evidence, we negotiated a settlement proposal from the tribunal.
Outcome: The parties concluded a settlement, recorded as an award on agreed terms.
The examples are anonymised and simplified. They illustrate typical situations; every case is different, and no particular outcome can be promised.
Frequently asked questions
Is arbitration more expensive than litigation?
For smaller amounts in dispute, usually yes. In complex large cases, the absence of a second instance often offsets the additional costs.
Can an arbitral award be challenged?
Only on a few grounds, for example serious procedural errors or a violation of public policy. The higher regional court has jurisdiction.
Last updated: · horak Rechtsanwälte, Hanover. General information under German law, not legal advice in an individual case.