Under a general contractor agreement, one company takes on all the construction work; under a turnkey or design-and-build agreement (Generalübernehmer, Totalunternehmer) it also takes on all or part of the design. The client has only one contractual partner – provided the contract fully describes what is owed.
Scope and lump-sum price
General contractor agreements are usually concluded at a lump-sum price. Under a detailed lump-sum contract, the work is described item by item; under a global lump-sum contract, the contractor owes a functioning building on the basis of a functional specification. The more global the description, the greater the contractor’s quantity and completeness risk – and the more important clear rules on quality, design approvals and changes become.
Interfaces and design
Conflicts frequently arise where the client’s design meets the general contractor’s execution. Who supplies which design, who checks it and who is liable for design errors must be expressly regulated. In a turnkey agreement, this includes the demarcation from the permit design and the adoption of preliminary designs.
Key provisions
- Contract documents and their order of precedence
- Completion dates, milestones and contractual penalties within the limits permitted for standard terms
- Change management and change order procedure
- Acceptance, partial acceptance and documentation
- Performance and defects securities
- Use of subcontractors, minimum wage and social security liability
Case studies
Global lump sum and missing building services
Situation: A general contractor argued that the ventilation system of a day-care centre was not included in the lump sum.
Approach: We showed from the functional specification and public-law requirements that the system was part of the result owed.
Outcome: The general contractor installed the system without additional payment.
Design responsibility in a turnkey agreement
Situation: An investor handed over a scheme design which turned out not to be capable of approval.
Approach: We analysed the contract clauses on the adoption and checking of the preliminary design.
Outcome: The additional costs were split according to each party’s share of responsibility, and the project continued.
Contractual penalty too high
Situation: A general contractor agreement provided for a contractual penalty of 0.5 percent per working day with no cap.
Approach: We challenged the clause as an invalid standard term.
Outcome: The client could only claim the delay damage it could actually prove.
The examples are anonymised and simplified. They illustrate typical situations; every case is different, and no particular outcome can be promised.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a general contractor and a turnkey contractor?
A general contractor carries out substantial parts of the construction work itself; a turnkey contractor (Generalübernehmer) subcontracts all the work and often also takes on the design.
Can the lump-sum price increase later?
Yes, for ordered changes or additional work and, in exceptional cases, where the basis of the transaction falls away.
Last updated: · horak Rechtsanwälte, Hanover. General information under German law, not legal advice in an individual case.