Baurecht · Architektenrecht · Immobilienrecht · Vergaberecht

02 · Design, engineering & development

Construction experts and technical construction law

Generally recognised rules of technology, DIN standards, trade rules and expert reports: most construction cases are decided where technology and law meet.

Whether construction work is defective rarely depends on the contract alone. It usually turns on technical standards – and on the assessment by experts. Our technical background helps us to review expert reports critically and to ask the right questions.

Generally recognised rules of technology

Work must comply with the generally recognised rules of technology – even without an express agreement. These are technical rules that are recognised as correct in science and have proven themselves in practice. DIN standards are presumed to reflect these rules but are not necessarily identical to them. The decisive point in time is generally acceptance. If the rules change during construction, the contractor must inform the client.

Technical standards and trade rules

  • DIN standards and EurocodesDesign, execution and testing, for example waterproofing, thermal and sound insulation, structures.
  • VOB Part C (ATV)General technical specifications for the individual trades, with rules on execution, ancillary work and invoicing.
  • Trade association rulesFor example the rules of the roofing trade or technical leaflets for plaster, screed and tiles.
  • Manufacturer specificationsProcessing guidelines and approvals; disregarding them frequently constitutes a defect.
  • Building regulationsTechnical building rules of the federal states, in particular on fire protection and structural stability.

Interfaces between trades

Many defects arise at the transitions: between shell and waterproofing, windows and façade, screed and floor covering, or building services and drywall. Every contractor must check the preliminary work of other trades and raise concerns. Construction schedules, interface records and clear coordination by site management and designers reduce the risk. When it comes to who is responsible for damage, a precise technical analysis of the cause is decisive.

Expert reports in construction

  • Private expert reports: commissioned by the client or contractor, for example to accompany acceptance, establish defects or review change orders. Costs may be recoverable as damages.
  • Court expert reports: commissioned by the court in independent evidence proceedings or litigation (sections 402 et seq. ZPO). The parties can raise objections, ask supplementary questions and request a hearing of the expert.
  • Expert determination: agreed by the parties and binding on both, except where obviously incorrect.

Rights, duties and liability of experts

Construction experts are obliged to be impartial, diligent and confidential. Publicly appointed and sworn experts are additionally subject to the rules of the appointing chamber. Private experts are liable to their client for defective reports under contract-for-work law. Court-appointed experts are liable for a report that is incorrect through intent or gross negligence (section 839a BGB). We advise experts on drafting contracts and represent them against liability claims.

Our services

  • Legal assessment of technical defects and deviations from standards
  • Selecting suitable experts and formulating questions for them
  • Critical review of expert reports, supplementary questions and challenges for bias
  • Contracts with experts and liability issues

Case studies

Expert report refuted with supplementary questions

Situation: A court-appointed expert considered a sound insulation defect not to be provable.

Approach: Together with a private expert, we formulated targeted supplementary questions on the generally recognised rules of technology.

Outcome: The expert corrected his findings, and the defect was recognised.

Rules of technology or contractual standard

Situation: A client demanded tiles laid to a tighter flatness tolerance than provided for in the DIN standard.

Approach: We examined which quality had been agreed in the contract.

Outcome: In the absence of a special agreement, the work was free of defects; the claim was dropped.

Expert determination for a fast construction process

Situation: On a commercial building, the parties were in dispute over the cause of cracks in the industrial floor.

Approach: We drafted an expert determination agreement with a recognised expert.

Outcome: The report was available after six weeks, and the parties implemented it without litigation.

The examples are anonymised and simplified. They illustrate typical situations; every case is different, and no particular outcome can be promised.

Frequently asked questions

Is work defective if it breaches a DIN standard?

As a rule, yes, because DIN standards are presumed to be generally recognised rules of technology. This presumption can be rebutted, however: a standard may be outdated and, conversely, work complying with a standard may be defective if it does not fulfil the agreed function.

Is a private expert report worthwhile before court proceedings?

Often, yes. A private expert report provides a sound basis for negotiations, for deciding on court action and for formulating precise questions for the court expert. In litigation, however, it only counts as qualified submissions by a party.

Last updated: · horak Rechtsanwälte, Hanover. General information under German law, not legal advice in an individual case.

Enquiry

Your question about Experts & technology

Briefly describe the facts. We will get back to you with an initial assessment of the approach and costs.

We use your details only to process your enquiry. For details, please see our privacy policy.

Encrypted transmission. An enquiry does not create a client relationship; deadlines cannot be met via this form.