Once construction is complete, use begins: buildings are let, leased or marketed through brokers. We advise landlords, tenants, investors and real estate brokers – with a focus on commercial properties.
Commercial tenancy law
In commercial tenancy law, freedom of contract largely applies; most of the protective provisions of residential tenancy law do not apply. Careful drafting is therefore all the more important:
- Permitted use and protection against competition – what may be operated in the premises, and may the landlord let to a competitor next door?
- Term, options and termination – fixed terms, renewal options, special termination rights
- Form: long-term commercial leases used to be subject to strict written form; since 1 January 2025, text form has been sufficient for new contracts. Formal errors can nevertheless lead to early terminability.
- Rent and rent adjustment – stepped and index-linked rent, turnover rent
- Service charges, maintenance and decoration – what can be passed on, and the limits of passing costs on in standard terms
- Tenant fit-outs and reinstatement – construction cost contributions, ownership of fixtures, condition on return
Residential tenancy law
For residential premises, the German Civil Code protects tenants comprehensively: protection against termination, caps on rent increases and the rent brake in tight housing markets, and rules on modernisation, service charge statements and deposits. We advise landlords and tenants, particularly on modernisation, new-build projects and larger residential complexes.
Typical points of dispute
- Defects and rent reductionConstruction defects, damp, noise from building work in the neighbourhood.
- Service chargesFormal and substantive errors in statements.
- TerminationNotice, eviction, return and claims for reinstatement or damages.
- Handover of newly built spaceDelayed completion, acceptance of the leased space, interface with the construction contract.
Brokerage law
A broker only earns commission if there is a valid brokerage agreement, the broker has identified or negotiated the opportunity, and the main contract has come about as a result of this activity (section 652 BGB). Additional rules apply to the sale of apartments and single-family houses to consumers: the brokerage agreement must be in text form, and if the broker was engaged by both sides, the commission must be split equally (sections 656a et seq. BGB).
- Types of brokerage agreement: simple brokerage mandate, sole mandate, qualified sole mandate
- Duties of the broker: disclosure, diligence and duties under the MaBV
- Liability for incorrect information in the sales brochure or breach of disclosure duties
- Forfeiture of the commission claim in the event of a serious breach of the duty of loyalty
Our services
- Drafting and reviewing commercial leases and addenda
- Rent adjustment, defects, rent reduction and termination of tenancies
- Enforcing and defending commission claims
- Brokerage agreements, sales brochures and liability
Case studies
Commercial lease for a medical practice
Situation: A doctor wanted to rent practice premises in a new building on a long-term basis.
Approach: We reviewed the lease regarding alterations, protection against competition, index-linked rent and questions of form.
Outcome: The lease was signed with balanced provisions.
Broker’s commission reclaimed
Situation: A buyer had paid commission although the broker was also acting for the seller and the rules on splitting the commission had not been observed.
Approach: We asserted that the commission agreement was invalid.
Outcome: The broker repaid part of the commission.
Rent reduction due to construction noise
Situation: A retailer was suffering from a major construction site in front of its shop.
Approach: We documented the drop in turnover and substantiated the rent reduction to the landlord.
Outcome: The parties agreed on a temporary rent reduction.
The examples are anonymised and simplified. They illustrate typical situations; every case is different, and no particular outcome can be promised.
Frequently asked questions
Do I have to pay the broker’s commission if I would have found the property without the broker?
The commission claim requires that the broker’s activity caused the contract to be concluded. If you already knew about the property and told the broker in good time, the claim may not arise. The details depend on how events unfolded.
Can the landlord of a shop increase the rent at will?
No. Even in commercial tenancy law, a rent increase during the term is only possible if it has been agreed in the contract – for example through stepped or index-linked rent – or if the tenant consents. Without such a provision, the only option is termination with an offer of new terms, insofar as the lease can be terminated by ordinary notice.
Last updated: · horak Rechtsanwälte, Hanover. General information under German law, not legal advice in an individual case.