With acceptance, the client approves the work as essentially in accordance with the contract. It has far-reaching legal consequences – for payment, the burden of proof and limitation. Defects are among the most frequent points of dispute in construction.
Acceptance and its consequences
- Payment falls due – under a BGB construction contract additionally after a verifiable final invoice has been issued
- Transfer of risk: the risk of accidental damage passes to the client
- Reversal of the burden of proof: after acceptance, the client must prove defects
- Start of the limitation period for defect claims
- Loss of rights regarding known defects or contractual penalties if they are not reserved
Acceptance can be formal (joint inspection with a record), implied (for example through use and payment without reservation) or deemed: if, after completion, the contractor sets a reasonable deadline for acceptance and the client does not refuse it by stating at least one defect, the work is deemed accepted (section 640(2) BGB). Consumers must be informed of this consequence. In the case of partial acceptance, the effects occur for the part accepted.
Refuse acceptance – or not?
The client may only refuse acceptance because of material defects. If it does so, the contractor can demand a joint condition survey (section 650g BGB). Obvious defects not recorded there are then, in case of doubt, presumed to have arisen after the survey. Careful preparation of acceptance is decisive for both sides.
The client’s defect rights
A defect exists if the work does not have the agreed quality, is not suitable for the intended use or does not comply with the generally recognised rules of technology. The client has the following rights (section 634 BGB, § 13 VOB/B):
- RemedyThe contractor may and must first remedy the defect itself; it must be given a reasonable deadline to do so.
- Self-remedyAfter the deadline has expired without result, the client can have the defect remedied by third parties and demand an advance on costs or reimbursement.
- Price reductionReduction of the price in proportion to the reduced value.
- RescissionFor significant defects – rarely sensible in construction law because of the difficulties of unwinding.
- DamagesCompensation for consequential losses, such as lost rent, expert costs or damage to other building elements.
Deadlines and limitation
| Claim | BGB | VOB/B |
|---|---|---|
| Defects in buildings | 5 years from acceptance (section 634a(1) no. 2 BGB) | 4 years from acceptance (§ 13(4) VOB/B) unless otherwise agreed |
| Work on land / installations requiring maintenance | 2 years | 2 years or 1 year (depending on maintenance contract and component) |
| Fraudulently concealed defects | Standard limitation period of 3 years from knowledge, but not before the warranty period expires | |
Limitation is suspended, among other things, by negotiations, independent evidence proceedings or an action. Under a VOB/B contract, a written notice of defects additionally starts a new two-year period for the defect notified (§ 13(5) no. 1 VOB/B). Under a BGB contract, by contrast, a mere letter to the contractor does not suspend limitation.
Our services
- Preparing and attending acceptance inspections, reviewing acceptance records
- Notices of defects with deadlines, actions for an advance on costs and price reduction
- Defending against unjustified defect claims and retentions
- Independent evidence proceedings and coordination with experts
- Calling or releasing warranty guarantees
- Deadline control and limitation management
Case studies
Acceptance refused without reason
Situation: A client refused to accept a detached house because of minor cosmetic defects.
Approach: We set a deadline for acceptance and classified the defects as immaterial.
Outcome: The effects of acceptance occurred; the contract price fell due less a retention for the outstanding work.
Defects remedied by a replacement contractor
Situation: A community of apartment owners found leaking balconies; the contractor did not respond.
Approach: After setting a deadline, we demanded an advance on costs and supported the award to a third-party contractor.
Outcome: The balconies were repaired, and the original contractor bore the costs.
Limitation calculated correctly
Situation: A client believed its claims for cracks in the screed were time-barred.
Approach: We established that, in the absence of formal acceptance, the period had started later.
Outcome: The claims still existed and were successfully enforced.
The examples are anonymised and simplified. They illustrate typical situations; every case is different, and no particular outcome can be promised.
Frequently asked questions
May I withhold part of the payment because of defects?
Yes. After acceptance, the client can refuse to pay an appropriate part of the price, usually twice the expected cost of remedying the defects (section 641(3) BGB). The retention should be justified and documented.
Who has to prove a defect?
Before acceptance, the contractor must prove that its work is free of defects. After acceptance, the client bears the burden of proof – unless it reserved the defect upon acceptance. That is exactly why a complete acceptance record is so important.
What if a defect only appears after years?
What matters is whether the limitation period has expired – for buildings under the BGB, five years from acceptance. The time of acceptance is decisive, not the time of discovery. In the case of fraudulently concealed defects or so-called organisational fault on the part of the contractor, longer liability may apply.
Last updated: · horak Rechtsanwälte, Hanover. General information under German law, not legal advice in an individual case.