A consumer construction contract exists where a business undertakes to a consumer to build a new building or to carry out substantial alterations to an existing building (section 650i BGB). The law attaches numerous protective provisions to this.
Obligations of the contractor
- Text form of the contract (section 650i(2) BGB)
- Building specification before the contract is concluded, with the minimum information under Article 249 EGBGB; ambiguities are construed against the contractor (sections 650j, 650k BGB)
- Binding information on construction time or the completion date
- Information on the right of withdrawal: the consumer may withdraw within 14 days; without proper information the period is extended to up to one year and 14 days (section 650l BGB, section 356e BGB)
- Handing over documents required for authorities or funding bodies (section 650n BGB)
Payments and securities
Interim payments may not exceed 90 percent of the agreed total price. With the first interim payment, the contractor must provide the consumer with security of 5 percent of the price for timely and defect-free completion. If the contractor itself requires security, the amount is capped (section 650m BGB). The contractor cannot demand a contractor’s security under section 650f BGB from a consumer.
Scope
Smaller works on an existing house, such as replacing the windows, are generally not a consumer construction contract. According to case law so far, a consumer who awards the trades separately also does not conclude a consumer construction contract for the construction of a „new building“. The classification determines the right of withdrawal and the payment rules and should be clarified before the contract is signed.
Case studies
Withdrawal after construction had started
Situation: A couple wanted to get out of a prefabricated house contract after a dispute over the fittings; the provider’s withdrawal information was defective.
Approach: We reviewed the withdrawal information and declared withdrawal within the extended period.
Outcome: The parties agreed to unwind the contract, with compensation for design services already provided.
Incomplete building specification
Situation: The building specification of a builder of solid houses contained no information on the insulation of the basement walls.
Approach: We interpreted the gap on the basis of the overall impression and customary standards.
Outcome: The builder installed the insulation at no extra cost.
Payment plan above 90 percent
Situation: A construction company had agreed a payment plan with consumers providing for 97 percent before completion.
Approach: We developed a payment plan for the company that complies with the law and adapted its template contracts.
Outcome: Future contracts are legally sound, and repayment risks were avoided.
The examples are anonymised and simplified. They illustrate typical situations; every case is different, and no particular outcome can be promised.
Frequently asked questions
Does the right of withdrawal also apply to notarised contracts?
No. If the contract has been notarised, there is no right of withdrawal under section 650l BGB.
What must a building specification contain?
Among other things, information on the type and scope of the works, building data, drawings, energy and sound insulation standards, construction method, interior finishing and construction time (Article 249 section 2 EGBGB).
Last updated: · horak Rechtsanwälte, Hanover. General information under German law, not legal advice in an individual case.