In construction law, deadlines and the choice of the right procedure are often decisive. This overview shows the main ways to enforce or defend rights under German law – out of court, before the civil and administrative courts and in public procurement.
Watch the deadlines: Many of the remedies listed here are subject to time limits – some of them very short, only a few days. Please seek advice early.
Out-of-court dispute resolution
- Negotiation and settlementThe fastest and usually the least expensive route – based on a sound legal and technical assessment.
- ConciliationA neutral conciliator proposes a settlement, for example under the German construction dispute rules (SL Bau) or before the conciliation bodies of the chambers.
- MediationA structured process in which the parties work out a solution themselves with the help of a mediator; particularly suitable for ongoing projects.
- AdjudicationA fast, provisionally binding decision by an expert adjudicator during the construction phase; common internationally as a dispute board.
- Expert determinationAn expert decides a technical question with binding effect, for example whether a defect exists or how much a change order is worth.
Civil court proceedings
Independent evidence proceedings (sections 485 et seq. ZPO)
Independent evidence proceedings preserve evidence before it is lost – for example when defects are about to be remedied or covered up. A court-appointed expert assesses defects, their causes and the cost of remedying them. The application suspends the limitation period, and the expert report can be used in later litigation.
Construction litigation
Claims for payment, defects and damages are heard by the civil courts; the regional courts and higher regional courts have specialised construction chambers and senates. Construction cases are characterised by extensive written submissions, expert reports and careful presentation of change orders, additional costs and disruption to the construction schedule.
Interim injunction
In summary proceedings, a contractor can in particular obtain the registration of a priority notice securing the builder’s mortgage. In disputes over instructions and payment for changes, section 650d BGB allows an interim injunction without the urgency having to be separately substantiated.
Documentary and payment order proceedings
Undisputed claims, or claims supported by documents (such as guarantees), can be turned into an enforceable title more quickly in payment order or documentary proceedings.
Arbitration
Arbitral tribunals decide confidentially, with final effect and through expert arbitrators – for example under the rules of the DIS, the ICC or the SL Bau. A valid arbitration agreement is required.
Administrative and administrative court proceedings
- Building permit procedure: preliminary building enquiry (outline decision), simplified and standard permit procedures, exemption from the permit requirement.
- Objection and action for issue of a permit: against the refusal of a building application or onerous conditions; depending on the federal state, an objection procedure comes first or an action is filed directly.
- Neighbour action and urgent application: neighbours can challenge a building permit and apply for suspension of its enforcement; developers defend their permit.
- Building control orders: defending against stop-work orders, prohibitions of use and demolition orders.
- Judicial review of plans (section 47 VwGO): court review of a development plan; the application must be filed within one year of publication.
Public procurement proceedings
- Complaint to the contracting authority: procurement errors must be raised with the contracting authority within short time limits (section 160(3) GWB).
- Review proceedings: before the public procurement tribunal for contracts above the EU thresholds; the application must be filed no later than 15 calendar days after notice that the complaint will not be remedied.
- Immediate appeal: against decisions of the procurement tribunal to the procurement senate of the higher regional court.
- Below the thresholds: legal protection through review bodies, state procurement laws and, where appropriate, interim injunctions before the civil courts.
Criminal and administrative fine proceedings
Accidents on site, undeclared work, breaches of minimum wage and posting rules or building without a permit can lead to investigations and fine proceedings. We represent companies and the individuals responsible and advise preventively on compliance.
All proceedings in detail
- Independent evidence proceedings – A court-appointed expert establishes defects, causes and costs before evidence is lost.
- Construction litigation before the civil courts – Construction cases are technical and lengthy. Winning them takes a well-thought-out strategy and clean pleadings from the outset.
- Interim injunctions in construction law – When time is short: we secure claims before facts are created on the ground.
- Payment order and documentary proceedings – Not every unpaid claim needs a long lawsuit. A payment order or documentary proceedings often lead to a title faster.
- Conciliation, adjudication and mediation – Many construction disputes can be resolved without going to court. We choose the right procedure and represent you in it firmly.
- Arbitration in construction matters – An arbitral tribunal decides confidentially and finally – with arbitrators who understand construction projects.
- Procurement review proceedings – In public procurement, days count. We assess complaints immediately and represent bidders and contracting authorities before the tribunal and the higher regional court.
- Building permits: procedure, objection and action – From the preliminary enquiry to the action for issue of a permit: we take projects through the approval process.
- Judicial review of development plans – Development plans can be reviewed by the higher administrative court. We represent owners, companies and municipalities.
- Neighbour protection and urgent proceedings – When building starts next door, every week counts. We assess neighbours‘ rights and protect developers against unjustified challenges.
- Criminal and fine proceedings in construction – After a site accident or a customs inspection, personal liability quickly becomes the issue. We defend contractors, site managers and designers.
Case studies
Quick settlement through conciliation
Situation: A client and a fit-out contractor were in dispute over change orders, and the project was at risk of coming to a standstill.
Approach: We agreed on conciliation and prepared the disputed items.
Outcome: The parties reached a settlement within four weeks.
Evidence secured before removal
Situation: A defective floor covering was to be replaced because of a change of tenant.
Approach: We initiated independent evidence proceedings before the floor was removed.
Outcome: The court established the defect, and the contractor paid the costs.
Successful procurement review
Situation: A bidder was excluded from a tender because of a formal error.
Approach: We raised a complaint and filed an application for review.
Outcome: The procurement tribunal ordered the bids to be re-evaluated.
The examples are anonymised and simplified. They illustrate typical situations; every case is different, and no particular outcome can be promised.
Last updated: · horak Rechtsanwälte, Hanover. General information under German law, not legal advice in an individual case.