Out-of-court procedures save time and money and often preserve cooperation on site. They are confidential and can be tailored to the specific features of a project. Which procedure fits depends on whether a binding decision, a technical assessment or a negotiated solution is sought.
Conciliation
A neutral conciliator, often a lawyer with construction experience or an expert, proposes a solution. The German construction dispute rules (Streitlösungsordnung für das Bauwesen, SL Bau) are widely used. The proposal is only binding if the parties accept it or have agreed this in advance.
Adjudication
In adjudication, an adjudicator decides a disputed question, such as a change order, within a short time. The decision is provisionally binding and is implemented until a court or arbitral tribunal decides otherwise. The procedure is particularly suitable for large projects where disputes must not block construction.
Mediation
In mediation, the parties work out a solution themselves with the support of a mediator. The mediator does not decide. The procedure is particularly useful where relationships are to continue, for example between client and designer or within communities of owners.
Mind the limitation period
Ongoing negotiations suspend the limitation period (section 203 BGB), but it is often unclear when negotiations have ended. We therefore expressly agree a waiver of limitation or a suspension before an out-of-court procedure begins.
Our services
- Drafting dispute resolution clauses in construction and design contracts
- Selecting procedures, conciliators and adjudicators
- Representation in conciliation, adjudication and mediation
- Securing the results through settlement agreements
Case studies
Change order dispute resolved by conciliation
Situation: On a new school building, the client and contractor were in dispute over twelve change orders, and construction was at risk of stalling.
Approach: We proposed conciliation under the SL Bau and prepared the change orders in a structured way for the conciliator.
Outcome: After two sessions, a conciliation proposal was accepted. Construction continued without interruption.
Mediation between client and architect
Situation: A family business and its long-standing architect were in dispute over cost overruns on a new hall.
Approach: We supported our client in mediation and assessed the liability risks in advance.
Outcome: The parties agreed on a fee reduction and continued working together on the next project.
Adjudication in industrial construction
Situation: On a logistics centre, it was disputed whether a changed sprinkler system was covered by the lump-sum price.
Approach: We submitted the application to the adjudicator named in the contract and presented a comparison with the contractual scope.
Outcome: The adjudicator awarded additional payment, which was paid immediately.
The examples are anonymised and simplified. They illustrate typical situations; every case is different, and no particular outcome can be promised.
Frequently asked questions
Is the outcome of conciliation binding?
Only if the parties agree this or accept the proposal. An accepted proposal has the effect of a settlement.
Can we still go to court later?
Yes, unless a binding agreement has been reached. Many contracts make conciliation a prerequisite for filing an action.
Last updated: · horak Rechtsanwälte, Hanover. General information under German law, not legal advice in an individual case.