Baurecht · Architektenrecht · Immobilienrecht · Vergaberecht

Procurement review proceedings

In public procurement, days count. We assess complaints immediately and represent bidders and contracting authorities before the tribunal and the higher regional court.

Once the EU thresholds are reached, bidders can have award decisions by public contracting authorities reviewed by the public procurement tribunal (sections 155 et seq. GWB). The procedure is fast and strict: anyone who misses a deadline loses their rights, and once a contract has been validly awarded it generally cannot be set aside.

Complaint

Before applying for review, the bidder must raise the infringement with the contracting authority. Infringements that have been recognised must be raised within ten calendar days (section 160(3) GWB). Infringements apparent from the contract notice or the tender documents must be raised at the latest by the end of the tender period. If the contracting authority does not remedy the complaint, 15 calendar days remain for the review application.

Advance notice and standstill

The contracting authority must inform unsuccessful bidders before the award (section 134 GWB). The contract may only be awarded 15 calendar days after the notice is sent, or ten calendar days if sent electronically. If a review application is submitted during this period, the contract may not be awarded.

Proceedings before the tribunal and the higher regional court

For contracts awarded by authorities in Lower Saxony, the Lower Saxony public procurement tribunal has jurisdiction. It is to decide within five weeks. An immediate appeal against its decision can be lodged within two weeks with the procurement senate of the Higher Regional Court of Celle. Below the thresholds, legal protection is limited; the main options here are complaints and urgent applications before the civil courts.

Our services

  • Immediate review of exclusions, evaluation and advance notices
  • Complaints and review applications for bidders
  • Representation of contracting authorities and joined parties
  • Immediate appeals, urgent applications and damages

Case studies

Exclusion for missing evidence corrected

Situation: A road construction company was excluded because a certificate of suitability was allegedly missing.

Approach: We raised a complaint in time and showed that the contracting authority should have requested the certificate subsequently.

Outcome: The tribunal ordered the contracting authority to re-evaluate the bids; our client won the contract.

Evaluation based on unclear criteria

Situation: In a tender for general design services, concepts were evaluated according to criteria not described in the documents.

Approach: We challenged the evaluation and requested access to the file.

Outcome: The tribunal ordered the evaluation to be repeated with transparent standards.

Contracting authority successfully defended

Situation: An unsuccessful bidder challenged the award of a fire station on the grounds of an abnormally low tender.

Approach: For the municipality, we presented the documented clarification of the price.

Outcome: The review application was rejected, and the contract could be awarded promptly.

The examples are anonymised and simplified. They illustrate typical situations; every case is different, and no particular outcome can be promised.

Frequently asked questions

What do review proceedings cost?

The tribunal’s fee depends on the contract value and usually lies between EUR 2,500 and EUR 50,000. In addition, there are lawyers‘ fees, which the losing party must reimburse.

What if the contract has already been awarded?

A validly awarded contract generally cannot be set aside. Exceptions apply where the advance notice was omitted or the contract was awarded directly without permission (section 135 GWB). Otherwise, damages remain.

Last updated: · horak Rechtsanwälte, Hanover. General information under German law, not legal advice in an individual case.