Baurecht · Architektenrecht · Immobilienrecht · Vergaberecht

Payment order and documentary proceedings

Not every unpaid claim needs a long lawsuit. A payment order or documentary proceedings often lead to a title faster.

Undisputed claims can be enforced quickly and inexpensively through the court payment order procedure (Mahnverfahren). Where documents are available, such as a guarantee, an acknowledgement or a confirmed account, documentary proceedings (Urkundenprozess) speed up enforcement even if the debtor raises objections.

The court payment order procedure

Applications for a payment order are filed exclusively online. A central court handles them; for applicants from Lower Saxony, this is the Local Court of Uelzen. The court does not examine whether the claim exists. If the debtor does not object within two weeks, an enforcement order can be applied for. Service of the payment order suspends the limitation period (section 204(1) no. 3 BGB) if the claim is sufficiently identified in the application.

When the payment order procedure is not suitable

If objections are to be expected, for example because of defects or disputed change orders, the procedure loses its value after an objection because the case is then transferred to the trial court. In such cases, filing an action directly is often faster. In addition, an imprecise description of several invoices may mean that the limitation period is not suspended.

Documentary proceedings

In documentary proceedings (sections 592 et seq. ZPO), only documents are admitted as evidence. The court refers objections that cannot be proven by documents to subsequent proceedings. The claimant thus quickly obtains a provisionally enforceable judgment. Typical applications in construction are claims under guarantees payable on first demand or absolute guarantees, and under written acknowledgements.

Our services

  • Reviewing the claim and choosing the fastest route to a title
  • Payment order applications with identification that safely suspends limitation
  • Documentary actions against guarantors and debtors
  • Enforcement, account garnishment and security mortgage

Case studies

Enforcement order within six weeks

Situation: An electrical contractor had been waiting months for payment of an accepted final invoice without any complaint about defects.

Approach: We applied for a payment order; the debtor did not object.

Outcome: After six weeks there was an enforcement order; the claim was paid after an account garnishment.

Guarantee in documentary proceedings

Situation: After a general contractor became insolvent, the guarantor refused to pay under a performance guarantee.

Approach: We sued the guarantor in documentary proceedings and had the objections referred to the subsequent proceedings.

Outcome: The client quickly obtained an enforceable judgment, and the guarantor paid.

Limitation averted despite a payment order

Situation: A contractor had itself applied for a payment order covering several invoices that were only described by a total sum.

Approach: We identified the individual claims in a supplementary action before the limitation period expired.

Outcome: The claims remained enforceable.

The examples are anonymised and simplified. They illustrate typical situations; every case is different, and no particular outcome can be promised.

Frequently asked questions

What does a payment order cost?

The court fees are half a fee based on the amount in dispute and therefore considerably lower than for an action. If the debtor is in default, the costs are generally recoverable.

Can I also claim a contractor’s security in the payment order procedure?

No. The payment order procedure is limited to money claims. We enforce the claim to security under section 650f BGB by action.

Last updated: · horak Rechtsanwälte, Hanover. General information under German law, not legal advice in an individual case.