Construction companies and tradespeople regularly perform in advance. If the client does not pay or becomes insolvent, considerable losses are at stake. The law provides effective security instruments – you just have to use them in time.
Contractor’s security under section 650f BGB
The contractor can demand from the client at any time – even after acceptance – security for the unpaid price, including change orders, plus 10 % for ancillary claims. A guarantee from a credit institution is customary. If the client does not provide the security within a reasonable period, the contractor can suspend work or terminate the contract.
This claim cannot be excluded by contract. Public clients and consumers concluding a consumer construction contract or developer contract are exempt. The contractor must reimburse the cost of the security up to 2 % per year.
Builder’s security mortgage (section 650e BGB)
Alternatively, the contractor can demand the registration of a security mortgage over the building plot – but only if the client is also the owner of the land. To secure priority, a priority notice is first registered by way of an interim injunction. The mortgage is particularly effective because it makes it harder to sell or mortgage the property.
Other security instruments
- Interim payments (section 632a BGB)Payment for proven work in the value of the work performed – limited to 90 % of the total price under consumer construction contracts.
- Payment plansClear instalments according to construction progress reduce the risk of performing in advance.
- Advance payment against a guaranteeAdvance payments against an advance payment guarantee protect both sides.
- Trade credit insuranceProtection against the client’s insolvency.
- Retention of titleOnly of limited effect for building materials, as they become an integral part of the land once installed.
Trades law
For trade businesses, further questions arise in addition to contract-for-work law: the German Crafts Code (Handwerksordnung) governs registration in the register of crafts and the master craftsman requirement in licensed trades. In addition, there are questions of documentation, the duty to check and warn about preliminary work by other trades (notice of concerns) and liability for installed materials.
If tradespeople install defective material, they can demand from the supplier not only replacement goods but also the costs of removal and installation (section 439(3) BGB). Separate, often short deadlines apply to enforcing these claims against the supplier.
Our services
- Demanding security under section 650f BGB with a deadline
- Interim injunction for registration of a priority notice for the security mortgage
- Receivables management, payment order proceedings and payment actions
- Reviewing and drafting payment plans and guarantees
- Notices of concerns, warnings and documentation
- Recourse against suppliers and subcontractors
- Advice in the event of insolvency of the client or a subcontractor
Case studies
Contractor’s security enforced
Situation: After delays in payment, a façade contractor feared losing its outstanding claim.
Approach: We demanded security under section 650f BGB and suspended the work after the deadline expired.
Outcome: The client provided a bank guarantee; the work continued.
Interim invoices enforced
Situation: A general contractor was only paying its subcontractor’s interim invoices slowly.
Approach: We set out the interim claims in a verifiable form and announced an action.
Outcome: The outstanding interim payments were settled within two weeks.
Security retention released
Situation: Five years after acceptance, a client was still holding back a warranty retention.
Approach: We demanded its return, pointing out that the security period had expired.
Outcome: The retention was paid out in full.
The examples are anonymised and simplified. They illustrate typical situations; every case is different, and no particular outcome can be promised.
Frequently asked questions
Can I still demand security after acceptance?
Yes. The claim to security under section 650f BGB also exists after acceptance and even after termination, as long as payment is outstanding. It is an effective means of pressure when the client alleges defects in order to delay payment.
What is a notice of concerns?
If the contractor has concerns about the intended method of execution, about materials supplied or about preliminary work by other contractors, it must inform the client in writing and without delay. If it fails to do so, it is liable for the resulting defects – even if the cause lies with another party.
Last updated: · horak Rechtsanwälte, Hanover. General information under German law, not legal advice in an individual case.