Architects bear great responsibility: for the design, function, costs and schedule of a construction project. The legal questions are correspondingly diverse – from the contract and fees to liability. We advise architects as well as clients.
The architect agreement
Since 2018, the architect and engineer agreement has been regulated separately in the German Civil Code (sections 650p et seq. BGB). Key points:
- Goal-definition phase: if the design goals have not yet been fixed, the architect first prepares a design basis with a cost estimate.
- Special right of termination: once these documents have been presented, the client can terminate the contract within two weeks (consumers only after being informed of this right), section 650r BGB.
- Partial acceptance: from acceptance of the last work of the executing contractor, the architect can demand partial acceptance of the services provided up to that point (section 650s BGB).
- Joint and several liability: if the architect is liable for a supervision error alongside the contractor, it can refuse performance as long as the client has not unsuccessfully set the contractor a deadline for remedy (section 650t BGB).
Common contract forms are the single contract for specific work stages, the staged contract with step-by-step commissioning, the general design contract and the project management agreement.
Fees under the HOAI
The German fee scale for architects and engineers (HOAI) divides services into nine work stages – from establishing the basis to post-completion services – and contains fee tables. Since the HOAI 2021, the fee tables are no longer binding but serve as guidance. Fees can be freely agreed; the agreement must be in text form. Without a valid agreement, the base rate applies.
- Invoicing based on eligible costs, fee zone and scope of services
- Lump-sum, time-based and success-based remuneration
- Verifiable final invoice and interim invoices
- Fees for design changes and repeated basic services
- Remuneration on termination of the architect agreement
Liability of the architect
Architects are liable for defects in their design, for errors in site supervision, for exceeding agreed construction cost caps and for errors in tendering and checking invoices. Typical liability cases are waterproofing and thermal insulation errors, designs that cannot be approved and inadequate supervision of particularly risky trade work. For building design, claims become time-barred five years after acceptance of the architect’s services. We examine liability claims, coordinate with the professional indemnity insurer and represent architects and clients in court.
Copyright in drawings and buildings
Designs and buildings can be protected by copyright as works of architecture. This concerns the use of drawings after termination of the architect agreement, conversions and alterations to the building, attribution and images in advertising and the media. As a firm with specialist lawyers (Fachanwälte) for copyright and media law and for intellectual property, we combine architects‘ law and copyright under one roof.
Our services
- Drafting and reviewing architect and general design agreements
- Fee agreements, fee calculations and fee actions
- Defending and enforcing liability claims
- Advice on professional law and in dealings with the chambers of architects
- Architects‘ copyright, rights of use and prohibitions on alteration
Case studies
Fees despite cost overrun
Situation: A client refused to pay an architect’s fees because construction costs turned out higher than expected.
Approach: We showed that no construction cost cap had been agreed and that the cost estimates had been updated.
Outcome: Following an agreement, the client paid most of the fees.
Liability for site supervision defended
Situation: An architect was held liable for execution errors by a screed layer.
Approach: We showed that this was simple work that did not require constant supervision.
Outcome: The action against the architect was dismissed.
Architect agreement with staged commissioning
Situation: A municipality wanted to commission an architect for a new day-care centre initially only for the design.
Approach: We drafted a contract with service stages, fees under the HOAI and a clear call-off provision.
Outcome: The municipality retained the flexibility to stop the project if funding was not granted.
The examples are anonymised and simplified. They illustrate typical situations; every case is different, and no particular outcome can be promised.
Frequently asked questions
Are the HOAI minimum rates still binding?
No. Since 1 January 2021, the HOAI fee tables are only guideline values. Fees can be freely agreed. Without an agreement in text form, the base rate applies – that is, the lower value of the fee table.
Is the architect liable for construction defects alongside the contractor?
If the defect is based both on an execution error and on a design or supervision error, the architect and contractor are jointly and severally liable. In the case of a pure supervision error, however, the client must first ask the contractor to remedy the defect (section 650t BGB).
May the client continue to use the drawings after termination?
That depends on the rights of use granted in the contract and on the stage of the design. In principle, the client may use paid-for drawings to construct the specific building. Caution is required, however, with designs protected by copyright and with alterations.
Last updated: · horak Rechtsanwälte, Hanover. General information under German law, not legal advice in an individual case.