Hardly any construction project is carried out exactly as planned. Design changes, additional work, deviations in quantities and disruption to the construction process lead to change orders – and to disputes over whether they are justified and how much they are worth.
When does a change order arise?
A change order requires that the work actually carried out deviates from the contractually owed scope of works. The specification, drawings, ground survey and agreed technical standards are decisive. Typical triggers are:
- changed or additional work ordered by the client
- changes in quantities under a unit price contract (under the VOB/B from a 10 % deviation, § 2(3) VOB/B)
- unforeseen ground conditions or existing building conditions
- work without an order that is subsequently acknowledged or was necessary
- extensions of construction time due to disruption within the client’s sphere
Payment for change orders
Under a BGB construction contract, additional payment is calculated on the basis of the costs actually required, plus reasonable mark-ups for general overheads, risk and profit (section 650c BGB). Alternatively, an original calculation deposited as agreed can be used. Until agreement is reached, the contractor can demand 80 % of the additional payment stated in its offer as an interim payment.
Under the VOB/B, changed work (§ 2(5)) and additional work (§ 2(6)) are generally paid on the basis of the original pricing; for additional work, the claim must be announced before the work is carried out. In recent years, the courts have increasingly focused on the costs actually required.
Construction time, disruption and delay
Delays are expensive: for the contractor because staff, equipment and site facilities are tied up for longer; for the client because of lost rent, financing costs and knock-on delays. Clean documentation is decisive:
- Notice of disruption (§ 6(1) VOB/B) without delay and in writing, stating the cause and the effect
- Extension of the completion periods and claims for damages or compensation (§ 6(6) VOB/B, section 642 BGB)
- Presentation of the disruption in relation to the actual sequence of works – a lump-sum calculation is not sufficient for the courts
- Contractual penalties: validity of the clause, reservation upon acceptance, no penalty where disruption lies within the client’s sphere
Interim payments and final invoice
Contractors can demand interim payments for work performed (section 632a BGB, § 16 VOB/B). After completion, the final invoice follows. Under a VOB/B contract, accepting the final payment without reservation can exclude further claims if a reservation is not declared and substantiated in time. We check final invoices for verifiability, measurements and change order items.
Our services
- Preparing and reviewing change order offers and claims for additional costs
- Assessing instructions and changes to the works
- Delay claims: disruption management and delay analysis, with experts where necessary
- Claiming or defending contractual penalties
- Reviewing interim and final invoices
- Urgent proceedings under section 650d BGB and payment actions
Case studies
Change order for different ground conditions
Situation: During sewer construction, a civil engineering contractor encountered soil classes not provided for in the bill of quantities.
Approach: We determined the scope of works on the basis of the ground survey and calculated the change order based on the costs actually required.
Outcome: After negotiations, the client paid around 85 percent of the change order.
Extension of time after design delay
Situation: Because detailed design drawings were late, a fit-out contractor could only start weeks later.
Approach: We reviewed the notices of disruption and prepared a presentation of the delay in relation to the actual sequence of works.
Outcome: The completion periods were extended, the contractual penalty fell away and standstill costs were reimbursed.
Excessive change orders rejected
Situation: A client received more than 40 change order offers from its general contractor for a residential project.
Approach: We checked each change order against the contract and prepared a list of items with reasons.
Outcome: More than half of the change orders were withdrawn, and the rest were adjusted by agreement.
The examples are anonymised and simplified. They illustrate typical situations; every case is different, and no particular outcome can be promised.
Frequently asked questions
Do I have to announce a change order before carrying out the work?
Under a VOB/B contract, the claim to payment for additional work must generally be announced before it is carried out (§ 2(6) VOB/B). Regardless of this, early written notice with a cost estimate is always advisable – it improves the evidence and avoids disputes.
May the contractor stop work if a change order is not paid?
A right to refuse performance exists only under narrow conditions, for example if the client seriously and finally refuses justified payment for a change order or does not provide security under section 650f BGB. Stopping work without justification can justify termination for good cause. Seek advice beforehand.
When is a contractual penalty invalid?
In standard terms, a contractual penalty is only valid if it is reasonably capped. According to the case law of the Federal Court of Justice, it may not exceed 5 % of the contract sum in total; the daily rate must also be moderate. In addition, the client must reserve the contractual penalty upon acceptance.
Last updated: · horak Rechtsanwälte, Hanover. General information under German law, not legal advice in an individual case.