Baurecht · Architektenrecht · Immobilienrecht · Vergaberecht

04 · Real estate, disputes & compliance

Construction disputes, litigation and arbitration

When negotiations fail: independent evidence proceedings, construction litigation, conciliation, mediation, adjudication and arbitration – strategic and cost-conscious.

Construction litigation is demanding: it requires precise preparation of technical facts, often extensive expert reports and patience. Together with you, we choose the right route – from a quick settlement to proceedings through all instances.

Strategy before proceedings

It starts with a sober analysis: how strong is your position legally and technically? What evidence is available? What costs and how much time can be expected? How will a dispute affect the ongoing project and the business relationship? On this basis, we decide together whether negotiation, an out-of-court procedure or litigation makes sense.

Out-of-court dispute resolution

  • ConciliationA neutral, expert conciliator proposes a solution, for example under the German construction dispute rules (SL Bau).
  • MediationWith the support of a mediator, the parties work out a viable solution themselves – confidential and forward-looking.
  • AdjudicationAn adjudicator decides quickly and on a provisionally binding basis so that the project can continue.
  • Expert determinationBinding clarification of individual technical questions by an agreed expert.

Independent evidence proceedings

Independent evidence proceedings (sections 485 et seq. ZPO) are one of the most important tools in construction law. A court-appointed expert establishes the condition of the building, defects, their causes and the cost of remedying them. Advantages:

  • Securing evidence before defects are remedied or covered up
  • Suspension of the limitation period (section 204(1) no. 7 BGB)
  • Binding effect of the expert report for later litigation
  • Often the basis for a settlement, so that main proceedings are not needed
  • Involvement of other parties through third-party notice

Construction litigation

Specialised construction chambers have been set up at the regional courts and construction senates at the higher regional courts for construction matters. Typical proceedings are claims for payment, actions for an advance on costs or damages for defects, change order and delay claims, and fee claims by architects and engineers. What matters is a coherent, verifiable presentation of the claim, the early involvement of experts and third-party notices to designers, subcontractors or insurers in order to secure recourse claims.

Arbitration

For large and international projects, an arbitral tribunal is frequently agreed – for example under the rules of the German Arbitration Institute (DIS), the ICC or the SL Bau. Advantages are confidentiality, the choice of expert arbitrators and the international enforceability of the award. FIDIC contracts provide for a Dispute Avoidance/Adjudication Board before arbitration.

Our services

  • Strategic case analysis and cost-benefit assessment
  • Representation in conciliation, mediation and adjudication
  • Independent evidence proceedings and attendance at site inspections
  • Construction litigation at all instances
  • National and international arbitration
  • Settlement negotiations

Case studies

Evidence proceedings instead of litigation

Situation: On a new building, the client and contractor were in dispute over the cause of damp in the masonry.

Approach: We initiated independent evidence proceedings and involved the designer.

Outcome: After the expert report, all parties reached an agreement without an action.

Successful appeal

Situation: At first instance, a contractor had been ordered to pay because of alleged defects.

Approach: On appeal, we showed errors in the assessment of the expert report.

Outcome: The higher regional court reversed the judgment and dismissed the claim.

Arbitration in plant engineering

Situation: A manufacturer was in dispute with a customer over the performance of a production plant.

Approach: We conducted the arbitration agreed in the contract.

Outcome: The arbitral tribunal awarded the outstanding purchase price.

The examples are anonymised and simplified. They illustrate typical situations; every case is different, and no particular outcome can be promised.

Frequently asked questions

How long does construction litigation take?

Construction cases often take one to two years at first instance, longer where extensive evidence is taken. Prior independent evidence proceedings can extend the overall duration but often lead to a settlement. We show you ways to speed up or avoid proceedings.

Who bears the cost of the expert report?

Initially, the applicant pays an advance. In the end, the losing party generally bears the costs of the proceedings, including the expert report. Legal expenses insurance often does not cover construction disputes, or only to a limited extent – we check this in advance.

Last updated: · horak Rechtsanwälte, Hanover. General information under German law, not legal advice in an individual case.

Enquiry

Your question about Litigation & arbitration

Briefly describe the facts. We will get back to you with an initial assessment of the approach and costs.

We use your details only to process your enquiry. For details, please see our privacy policy.

Encrypted transmission. An enquiry does not create a client relationship; deadlines cannot be met via this form.